Why do dogs make people feel better just by watching them? And more importantly, does a person’s mood change the way they read canine emotions? A new study from Arizona State University reveals a surprising distortion in how humans perceive dogs’ feelings, and the results challenge long-held assumptions in psychology.

The research, led by Holly G. Molinaro and Clive D.L. Wynne and published in PeerJ, shows that watching videos of dogs improves mood, even when the dogs look uncomfortable or distressed. But the real twist is how people interpret those dogs’ emotions afterward, depending on what dog images they saw moments earlier.

advertisement

Watching Dogs Boosts Mood, Even When the Dogs Aren’t Happy

Nearly 600 undergraduate students took part in two experiments. Each participant watched short, silent video clips of three dogs, Oliver, Canyon, and Henry, displaying:

• Happy behavior
• Neutral behavior
• Mildly upset behavior (such as reacting nervously to a vacuum or a cat)

Across the board, participants reported feeling better after watching the videos.

That held true even when some of the dogs showed signs of discomfort.

Previous research has shown that petting, walking, or working with dogs in therapy sessions can lift mood. What makes this study unique is that even brief, passive viewing of dogs on screen, with no sound, no direct contact, and no elaborate setting, still reliably improved how people felt.

Dogs, it seems, don’t even need to be physically present to brighten a person’s day.

The Mind-Bending Twist: Dog Images Reverse Emotional Judgments

The biggest surprise emerged in the second experiment.

Participants were first “primed” with emotional images, either happy dogs or distressed dogs, before watching the dog videos. These images successfully altered participants’ moods. However, when they were asked to rate how the video dogs were feeling, something unexpected happened:

• Participants who viewed happy dog photos rated the video dogs as feeling more negative.
• Participants who viewed distressed dog photos rated the video dogs as feeling more positive.

This is the opposite of what is typically seen in human-focused psychology experiments.

The Emotional Congruence Effect, And Why Dogs Break It

Psychologists have long documented the “emotional congruence effect”: the tendency for people in a good mood to see the world more positively and those in a bad mood to see things more negatively. But when the emotional content comes from dogs, the mind appears to flip that rule upside down.

Researchers call this pattern a contrast effect. The brain interprets what it sees next as a kind of emotional “opposite” of what came first, but in this study, that occurred specifically within the realm of dog imagery.

When participants first viewed sad or distressed dog images, the dogs in the following videos appeared happier by comparison. When they viewed joyful, happy dog images first, the same video dogs seemed less happy.

Why Only Dog Images Triggered the Effect

Here’s another intriguing detail: when the researchers primed participants with emotional images of people, landscapes, or objects, the contrast effect did not occur.

Only dog photos, not human faces, not nature scenes, not everyday objects, caused people to misread how dogs in the videos were feeling.

The researchers suggest that dog images may activate especially strong emotional and cognitive shortcuts because of the deep bond many humans share with dogs.

advertisement

How This Could Affect Dog Owners, Trainers, Vets, and Shelter Staff

These findings go beyond the lab. They could affect how dog owners and professionals interpret everyday canine behavior.

1. Social Media May Distort How People Read Their Own Dogs

Scrolling through certain types of dog content could subtly skew perception:

• Watching a feed full of happy, playful dog videos may make a person’s own dog seem sadder or less content by comparison.
• Reading about abused or neglected dogs may make a person’s own dog seem happier and more relaxed than they truly are.

In other words, the brain might be comparing a real dog’s subtle expressions against extreme examples seen online, rather than evaluating that dog’s emotional state objectively.

2. Professionals May Misread Stress or Comfort

Shelter workers, veterinarians, and dog trainers rely heavily on accurately reading canine body language. If their perception can be influenced by dog imagery viewed just before handling a dog, it could affect:

• Behavioral assessments
• Handling and restraint decisions
• Stress and fear recognition
• Judgments about welfare and quality of life

A skewed emotional read, even if unintentional, could lead to choices that don’t fully match the dog’s actual emotional state.

3. Dog Owners May Overreact, or Underreact

A pet parent who just watched a stream of joyful, high-energy dog videos might assume their own dog is unhappy when that dog is perfectly calm and content. On the other hand, someone exposed to upsetting dog stories might underestimate their dog’s anxiety or stress, because the dog looks “fine by comparison.”

None of this happens consciously. It’s a subtle, automatic contrast effect, but it may influence how people respond to their pets.

Why This Study Matters

The research involved undergraduate students, mostly aged 18 to 21, and used only three individual dogs across nine videos. More research with a broader range of participants, breeds, and behaviors would help clarify the robustness of this effect.

Still, the study raises important questions about how accurately humans can read dogs’ emotions, especially after exposure to emotionally charged dog imagery online or in the media.

One encouraging takeaway is clear: dogs tend to make people feel better, even through a screen. The mood-boosting effect remained, even when the clips included mild canine discomfort.

advertisement

Bottom Line: Dogs Make Us Happy, But They Also Bend Our Emotional Radar

This Arizona State University study reveals an unexpected nuance in the human–dog bond:

• Watching dogs generally improves human mood, even without direct interaction.
• Dog-specific images can distort how people interpret canine emotions afterward.
• The contrast effect appears unique to dog imagery, not to images of humans, landscapes, or objects.
• Social media and other dog-focused content may subtly shape how owners, trainers, and professionals “read” dogs in real life.

In short, dogs change how people feel and how they think in surprisingly complex ways.

As scientists continue to explore why this happens, one thing remains certain: the human–dog relationship is more profound, more emotional, and more psychologically intricate than many ever imagined.

advertisement